Nicky’s offers easy ways to order!

Order Online for Carryout

Call (773) 233-3072 and place your carryout order.

Salads

Greek Salad12

Romaine, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, kalamata olives, feta cheese, oregano & pepperoncini peppers

Chicken Caesar Salad13

Romaine, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoncini & grated parmesan w/ grilled chicken & caesar dressing

Chopped Chicken Salad13

Romaine, onions, tomatoes, crumbled blue cheese, bacon, tortilla strips & grilled chicken

Southwest Chicken Salad13

Romaine, onions, tomatoes, corn, black beans, shredded Monterey Jack, tortilla strips, grilled chicken & chipotle ranch

Buffalo Chicken Salad13

Romaine, onions, tomatoes, crispy onions, blue cheese, chicken (grilled or crispy), & buttermilk ranch or blue cheese

Asian Chicken Salad13

Romaine, grilled chicken, red cabbage, carrots, onions, cilantro, water chestnuts, wonton strips, Asian ginger dressing

BBQ Chicken Salad13

Romaine, BBQ chicken, onions, corn, tomatoes, jalapeños, shredded mozzarella, & tater tots

Jerk Chicken Salad13

Romaine, onions, grilled jerk chicken, tomatoes, shredded mozzarella, mango & banana chips

Vegan Buffalo Chicken Salad14

Romaine lettuce, crispy vegan Buffalo chicken, tomatoes, onion, and vegan cheese, served with a vegan ranch dressing

Ahi Tuna Salad14

Romaine lettuce, seared rare ahi tuna, red and green onion, avocado, watermelon radish, wonton strips, tuxedo sesame seeds & ginger dressing.

Add Extra: Chicken +3.50 | Dressing +1.00, | Avocado +2.00 | Pita Bread +1.75

Sandwiches

Chicago Style Hot Dog4
Vienna Beef w/ mustard, relish, onions, pickles, tomatoes, peppers & celery salt
American Wagyu Dog6
Snake River Farms 100% American Wagyu beef dog smoked over hardwood and served with Chef Alberto’s kimchi slaw.
Italian Beef10
On Turano french bread w/ sweet or giardiniera peppers
Italian Sausage8
Fontanini Italian sausage on Turano French bread, dipped in red gravy & topped w/ sweet or giardiniera peppers
Italian Beef & Sausage Combo12
Italian Beef & Fontanini sausage on Turano French bread, dipped in red gravy & topped w/sweet or giardiniera peppers
Smoked Polish Sausage6
On poppy seed bun with mustard, onions, relish, tomatoes, pickles & sport peppers
Nicky’s Nashville Hot Chicken 8
Hand breaded fried chicken breast brushed with our own Nashville hot sauce, house sweet & spicy aioli, coleslaw & pickle on brioche
Pulled Pork9
Slow roasted & smoked pulled pork on a brioche bun with smoky bbq & pickles
Gyros9
The classic, lamb gyros off the spit served on pita w/ housemade tzatziki, red onion & tomatoes
Chicken Gyros10
Chicken sliced off the spit & served on a pita with housemade tzatziki, red onion & tomatoes
Corned Beef on Marbled Rye10
Piled high corned beef brisket served on marble rye with mustard, & Swiss
Fried Green Tomato9
Crisp slices of hand-breaded green tomato on country sourdough bread with pimento cheese, bacon & lettuce
Fried Oyster Po Boy10
Hand breaded East Coast Oyster, lettuce, tomato, pickle, & homemade tartar sauce on French bread
Grilled Cheese 5
Two slices of cheddar & two slices of Swiss
 
Patty Melt 9
Two 1/4 lb. char-broiled beef patties on marble rye with cheddar & grilled onions
 
Filet Mignon Sliders 15
Three beef tenderloin sliders on garlic buttered pretzel buns topped with horseradish havarti cheese. Served with a side of spicy mustard aioli
 
Fried Haddock8

1/2 lb. sustainably sourced haddock filet with beer-battered coating fried crisp & served w/ tartar sauce, lettuce, tomatoes & cheese

Blackened Catfish10

5–7 oz. grilled fillet served on soft garlic bread w/ Cajun mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, & cheese

Shrimp Po’Boy10
Lightly fried Buffalo shrimp served on garlic bread with remoulade, lettuce & tomatoes
 
Aged Rib-Eye Steak10
7 oz. aged ribeye steak served on garlic French bread with bistro sauce and grilled onions
 
Philly Cheese Chicken or Steak10

On footlong soft French bread w/ grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms & mounds of provolone cheese

Char-broiled Chicken on a Pita9

Marinated & char-broiled chicken breast sliced & served on a pita with mayo, tomatoes & lettuce & your choice of one of our special sauces

Lobster Roll16

Served hot with melted butter and chives on a split top bun with a side of Cape Cod potato chips and a pickle

Smoked Brisket Sandwich9

House smoked brisket with Carolina bbq sauce, slaw & a fried onion ring

Texas Hot Sausage9

Spiced beef & pork link on buttery split top bun with our own Chicago sauce & roasted red peppers

Burgers

Hamburger6
1/4 lb. char-broiled burger on brioche bun with ketchup, mustard, pickles, lettuce, tomatoes & grilled onions. Cheese available as add-on
Bacon Cheeseburger8
1/4 lb. cheeseburger with Applewood smoked bacon on brioche bun with ketchup, mustard, pickles, lettuce, tomatoes, grilled onions & cheddar cheese
Big Baby8
Two char-broiled fresh Angus beef patties, cheddar, grilled onions, pickles, ketchup & mustard on brioche bun
Filet Mignon Sliders 15
Three beef tenderloin sliders on garlic buttered pretzel buns topped with horseradish Havarti cheese. Served with a side of spicy mustard aioli.
The 1946 Burger9
1/2 lb. blend of brisket, short rib, and chuck topped with cheddar, grilled onions, lettuce, pickles, & Dijonnaise on brioche
1946 Sunrise9
Signature 1/2 lb. blend of brisket, short rib, and chuck with a fried egg, cheddar cheese, & bacon on brioche
1946 Bacon Bleu9
Signature 1/2 lb. blend of brisket, short rib, & chuck with blue cheese & bacon on brioche
Muddy Waters Burger 12
1/2 lb. ground bison, boar, Wagyu beef & elk on brioche with avocado, fresh jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, red onion, tomato, lettuce & chipotle mayo
Double Gyros Angus Cheeseburger11
Featured on “Chicago’s Best”! Two char-broiled fresh 1/4 lb. Angus beef patties, cheddar, thinly sliced gyros, grilled onions, pickles, tomatoes, lettuce, ketchup, mustard, & tzatziki on brioche
Turkey Burger9
1/3 lb. fresh ground turkey patty w/ grilled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & cheddar on brioche
Salmon Burger9
American ground salmon patty on brioche bun with garlic aioli, lettuce, tomatoes, & red onion
Lamb Burger12
1/2 lb. ground lamb patty with Swiss, Dijon mustard, lettuce, tomato, & grilled onions on brioche
‘Beyond Meat’ Veggie Burger9
1/4 lb. veggie patty with provolone, mayo, mustard, tomatoes, lettuce, pickles, & red onion on brioche
Vegan Big Baby14
Two char-broiled ‘Beyond Meat’ 1/4 lb. patties, your choice of vegan or cheddar cheese, grilled onions, pickles, ketchup & mustard on brioche bun

Add Extra: Applewood Bacon +2.00 | Avocado +2.00 | Fried Egg +2.00

Combo Meals

Served with large skin-on fries & large drink

#1 Gyros Sandwich13
#2 Big Baby (DBL Cheeseburger)12
#3 Turkey Burger12
#4 Nicky’s Nashville Hot Chicken12
#5 Aged Ribeye Steak13
#6 Italian Beef13
#7 Two Vienna Beef Hot Dogs9
#8 Fried Haddock Sandwich11
#9 Smoked Polish Sausage10
#10 Philly Cheese Steak14
#11 Char-Broiled Chicken on Pita13

Entrees

Gyros Platter17
Off the spit gyros served with 2 pita breads,, fries, salad with feta and kalamata olives and tzatziki on the side
Oven Roasted Greek Chicken15
Half chicken oven roasted with greek spices served with fries, salad and garlic bread
Burnt Ends16
Smoked beef brisket tossed in sweet BBQ sauce and served on garlic bread with fries and slaw.
Fried Jumbo Shrimp17

7 hand breaded jumbo shrimp lightly fried served with fries, salad and garlic bread

Blackened Catfish17

2 blackened and grilled catfish fillets served with fries, salad and garlic bread

Wings & Tenders

Bayou Hot, Memphis Mild, or Mango Habañero Sauce

6 Piece Wings6
12 Piece Wings11
4 Piece Tenders6
8 Piece Tender11

Vegan

‘Beyond Meat’ Veggie Tacos7

Two warm flour tortillas filled with seasoned Beyond Meat crumbles, vegan cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and Mani’s house-made salsa. 

‘Beyond Meat’ Vegan Sausage8

100% plant-based, Italian sausage from Beyond Meat in your choice of spicy or sweet flavors with accompanying toppings. Served on toasted Turano French bread.

‘Beyond Meat’ Vegan Brat8

A fresh Turano pretzel bun holds a grilled Beyond Meat bratwurst, topped with sweet pickle relish, grilled onions, and mustard.

‘Beyond Meat’ Veggie Burger9

Meet the world’s first plant-based burger that looks, cooks, and satisfies like beef–without gluten, soy, or GMOs. Vegan cheese available!

Vegan Big Baby14

Two charbroiled ‘Beyond Meat’ patties, cheddar, grilled onions, pickles, ketchup & mustard on brioche bun

Vegan Shrimp Po’Boy11

Shock’n Shrimp from Good2Go Veggie, vegan remoulade, lettuce, tomatoes, and pickles on a Turano French roll.

Vegan Jerk Chick’n on a Pita9

Gardein Meatless Chick’n Breast strips with oregano, lemon, garlic, & jerk sauce in a warm pita with romaine, tomatoes, grilled onions & vegan mayo.

Vegan Buffalo Chicken Salad14

Romaine lettuce, crispy vegan Buffalo chicken, tomatoes, onion, and vegan cheese, served with a vegan ranch dressing

Vegan Nashville Hot Chicken Tenders7

4 crispy vegan chicken tenders tossed in Nashville hot sauce

Vegan Nachos7

Fried tortilla chips, vegan nacho cheese, seasoned Beyond Meat crumbles, & jalapeños.

Vegan Shiitake Mushroom Potstickers7

Bok choy, carrot & shiitake mushroom filling seasoned with garlic, ginger & sesame, folded into a wheat flour wrapper, & fried crisp. Served with pineapple chili dipping sauce.

Vegan Shrimp Dinner19

Fried vegan shrimp with toasted garlic bread, crispy fries, and a side salad

Vegan Handspun Shake7

Sides

French Fries4
Sweet Potato Fries6
Cheddar Fries5
Parmesan Truffle Fries7
Pickle Fries7
Onion Rings6
Chicken Tamale3
Pizza Puff4
Southwest Chicken Eggrolls8
Chicken Potstickers7
Vegan Shiitake Mushroom Potstickers7
BBQ Pulled Pork Nachos14
Lobster Ceviche14
Pulled Pork Poutine14
Vegan Nachos7
Spicy Cheese Curds7
Crab Rangoon8
Crab & Shrimp Spring Rolls8
Crab Cake Bites9
Fried Avocado Slices7
Mexican Street Corn Bites8
Buffalo Chicken Empanada9

Soups

Mushroom & Brie Bisque6
Chili6
Lobster Bisque6
Crawfish Gumbo6

Drinks

Fountain Pop 24oz2